
Nobody has enjoyed the accusations against defrocked ref Tim Donaghy more than I. First of all, there are the gambling allegations, which are juicy, but then you get the even juicier "he was always a psycho" stories- like the one from Donaghy's mailman, who says that Donaghy once tried to run him off the road. Or, even better, his neighbor, who accused him of setting their tractor on fire. Ah... sounds like someone with the mental fortitude to referee the most hotly contested and important playoff games!
Of course, I love the NBA, but anything that brings to light the staggering incompetence of the front office and officials is a good thing in my book. Finally, FINALLY, David Stern is getting some heat. I*Heart*Celtics has been
bitching about the refs for years. So has everyone else that watches the league. They simply don't get the job done. Let's see how he does...
10:58
I have to decide which network to watch this press conference. CNN is too busy self-fellating about their brutally unwatchable Youtube debates last night, and the very possibility that Anderson Cooper would make me angry enough to pull a Donaghy and assault my mailman. ESPN has Skip Bayless!? Good gravy!! Meanwhile, Fox News has some guy that looks like Jim Lampley's screw-up cousin reading off of cue cards. Looks like it's Fox News for BP!

11:06
Here comes Stern. All cell phones and blackberries are turned off.
11:07
Stern looks visibly upset. His voice is trembling, even. My guess is that he knows a lot more than he will say in this press conference, and this story is going to get a lot, lot worse. I have never seen Stern look so upset.
11:10
Stern outlines the ways that the NBA prevents gambling on games. They have former FBI agents, Secret Service, and undercover cops working for them in security roles.
11:11
Stern drops the first "since 9/11" reference. When you're taking plays out of the Dubya playbook, you're in rough shape. He goes on and on about all the people they employ to prevent point shaving and illegal betting. The strategy here, of course, is to hammer you with so much random information that you zone out and say, "Wow, they really try hard. There's nothing they could have done." It sounds as though they have their own MI6 bureau, for crying out loud. Then, you look at a picture of Tim Donaghy and think, "THIS knuckle-dragger and some dumbass bookie friend could do it!?" Something doesn't add up here.
11:16
Stern talks about the neighbor dispute from January, 2005. YES!!! This is why I was waiting for. Of course, Stern doesn't give any of the "set his neighbor's tractor on fire" details, he skips over it, but says that the NBA sent an investigator over. I am completely unimpressed with his answer here. He doesn't give any information at all. In fact, he didn't even mention the word "tractor".
11:18
Investigators tell Stern that he was allegedly gambling at the Borgata in Atlantic City. However, the NBA's super agents couldn't find any evidence that he was gambling. However, because of the neighbor dispute and ensuing investigation, Donaghy was prohibited from working the second round of the playoffs that year as a punishment. Interesting! Clearly, the NBA understood that the guy was a lunatic and they
didn't do much about it.
11:21
Donaghy is "top tier of performance" among NBA officials. The easy conclusion is- he's one of the best you got, and he's under investigation for point shaving and spends his off days driving his neighbor's golf cart into a ravine.... yikes.
11:22
Fast forward to June 20th of this year, when the FBI calls about an investigation of an NBA referee. This is the first the NBA knew about gambling.
11:24
Donaghy is accused of betting on NBA games, Stern is "not positive" it was games he worked. He "maybe" bet on other games he didn't work. He is, "accused of providing information to others for the purpose of allowing them to profit on the betting on NBA games."
11:26
Stern lets us know that Donaghy worked 139 regular season games and 8 playoff games in the last two years, the only years where he is suspected of gambling. Stern wants to make it clear that Donaghy is the only referee that has been accused of anything illegal (gambling or otherwise).
11:27
"All of my knowledge is secondhand." Nice deflection! This sets up Stern to easily deflect every goddamn question in the Q&A session.
11:28
Stern denies knowing that Donaghy was betting on games during the season. He acknowledges the investigation back in 2005 into Donaghy's dispute with his neighbor, but insists that it wasn't a gambling investigation.
11:29
This is the "most serious...and worst" situation that he has ever experienced. "We pledge that we will do everything...[that we can]...to continue to assure our fans that we are doing the best that we possibly can."
11:31
Insists that the officiating staff is "the best in the world" and that the games are "still decided on their merit". Alright......
11:32
Q&A time!
Good question by the Philly Daily News, "are you surprised that this slipped through the cracks?"
His answer is, "Yes." Then he goes rambling about double agents that turn against their country. He then admits that the "system should have been better". I am getting the distinct impression that Stern is not going to be forthcoming at all.
11:35
Rachel Nichols throws him a bone and asks him about his emotional state. Who couldn't see this coming? A touchy-feely question from Rachel Nichols... pity points! Pity points! He gets to talk about going to the NBA family picnic. Man oh man. This guy is a pro. I am going to come back to this later because I hate this kind of journalism. My guess is that Rachel Nichols gets a little kickback from the League for asking such a softball question. All this does is allow Stern to take the stance of, "I'm a nice guy, I try hard, I feel betrayed" to get the public sentiment behind him. I hope the questions get better.
11:37
Stern insists that Donaghy is a "rogue, isolated criminal," and that the refs do a great job most of the time. However, he doesn't really discuss how he could possibly KNOW that he's the only ref because the system doesn't catch anybody! The system doesn't even raise a red flag when the refs act like psychopaths!
11:42
Stern blames the media for giving the impression that the allegations are "escalating". Sure David, finding out that one of your refs is in the mob's pocket and receiving death threats is the media's problem. They're the ones blowing this out of proportion. You can always blame the media. Always. There is no better straw man. Stern is getting oddly defiant. YOU called this press conference, you f*cking gremlin!
11:44
"On the basis of my current understanding, this is an isolated incident." However, he won't comment about other refs possibly under investigation.
11:45
David's getting punchy! When asked about whether the reporter is "reading him right" about inconclusive evidence about specific point shaving. Stern snaps back, "You don't have to read me, you can ask me!" Then, he has to "choose his words carefully," and then gives no answer. What's with the attitude, David? I understand that he can't comment on some issues, but I can't stand his arrogant tone with these reporters.
11:47
Donaghy's neighbor was "menacing" him?!? THIS is the story, people!
11:48
Philadelphia Daily News asks about Donaghy's extensive anger issues, which apparently involve "postal workers", "fellow referees", and "golf courses". Apparently, the "sheer volume" was enough to threaten termination and to reprimand him, but not enough to fire him. There's your great system at work, numbnuts.
11:57
The Washington Post's Sally Jenkins finally asks the question about the Spurs-Suns playoff game. Thank you, Ms. Jenkins! Of course, Stern deflects the question, even though we all know damn well that game was tainted. That game may have ruined the whole f-ing league, and Stern skips right over it. Dammit.
11:58
Fox News switches to President Bush's press conference. This isn't the train wreck I wanted! I wanted the NBA's train wreck. I am forced to switch to ESPN.
12:00
There has only been one accusation of illegal gambling activity that he remembers, from 20 years ago, involving "a timer". If you can't trust your timers, who can you trust?
12:02
Gambling of all forms is prohibited by the NBA, with the exception of the "racetrack in the summertime," which was "bargained for by the Union." Every reporter in the room looks confused.
12:10
The good newspapers are asking the good questions... Wall Street Journal guy asks why the NBA didn't realize that he was calling more fouls and technical fouls than most refs. Stern denies those statistics. Good move. I wish he had to answer to
this guy, or
this article. How can Stern sidestep that question!?
Then, the WSJ guy follows up with asking whether the NBA should pay the refs more, Stern responds that Donaghy gets paid $260,000. That is interesting.
12:13
The AP guy asks why Stern has condemned Donaghy when he hasn't been charged with anything, to which Stern says Donaghy's lawyer has informed the NBA that Donaghy is considering a plea.
ESPN's audio feed dies. Alright, I guess that's it. Now we get Jay
"Want To See What's In My Pants?" Crawford and Hubie "Dawn of the Dead" Brown. Big surprise, the ESPN people loooooove Stern's performance. Of course they do! They're friggin' business partners!
Alright, that's it, I guess, the TV is off. Here's what I think.
First and foremost, this story is going to get a lot worse for the NBA. Second, David Stern looked visibly shaken, defended his system, and accepted almost no responsibility for Donaghy's actions. I'll bet Stern gets praise for his performance, but it just pissed me off. He dodged questions (understandably, for some), defended himself and his crappy-ass failure of a ref-checking system, chastised the media (WTF), and didn't give me any indication that he knew what he was doing going forward. There was NO discussion as to how he can improve his system, NO discussion as to why Donaghy's psychotic personal history, NO discussion of the destroyed Phoenix-San Antonio series, and worst of all, NO discussion as to how Stern plans to address the abysmal refereeing in general in the NBA!
David, we all know that the reffing is, at best, inconsistent, and at worst, atrocious. Yet, you continue to defend your refs because you're too proud to admit that the league is a laughingstock BECAUSE of its officiating,
not because A.I. wears a do-rag or 'Melo wears XXXXXXXXXL sweatpants below his ass.
I would predict that the situation will not improve. The guy in charge believes that the WNBA is valuable and that the refs that gift-wrapped the last two NBA Championships for the Heat and the Spurs, respectively, are competent. What a joke.